Back

Back

Industry Insights

How to Handle Tenants Who Push Back on a Rent Increase

Andrew Littlefield of Cubby

Andrew Littlefield

・

Share:

Ask self-storage managers what tenants complain about most and you’ll hear the same answer. “The biggest complaint is rate increases,” Jessica Johnson of The Storage Group told Modern Storage Media this summer.

The complaints are loud, but the people making them are a small group. Only about 7% of customers who get a rent increase call to ask for relief, according to Adam Burnam, who oversees operations and innovation at StorageMart and spoke on Cubby’s State of Self Storage webinar this month. When his team makes an offer on that first call, 95% accept it.

And many of the callers are long-term renters, some already paying above street rate. The customers who accept relief “tend to be our longest-staying, most valuable customers,” says Burnam.

Most Tenants Won’t Leave Over a Reasonable Increase

The fear behind most fumbled pushback calls is that the tenant is about to walk. The data says that’s rarely true for a moderate increase.

In Cubby’s study of 74,000 leases across 68 operators, a first-year rate increase raised the monthly move-out rate by 0.18 percentage points against a 9.2% baseline, a difference too small to be statistically significant. Retention barely moved for increases up to about 30%. It started to erode past about 50%, and increases above 100% left retention about 16 points below baseline at 90 days, often on units that had been rented at a deep promotional discount.

The State of Self Storage report points the same way for long-term tenants, though churn rises at a lower threshold there. Those with no increase moved out within 90 days about 8% of the time, and those with an increase under 8% moved out about 8.5% of the time. Churn picked up noticeably once increases reached 20% to 25%.

For reference, standard increases typically run 8% to 15% per customer, according to Mike Scott of Spartan Investment Group. Most tenants absorb that without a word, so the ones who call are telling you something worth hearing.

Most Pushback Starts With a Surprise

Many pushback calls start with an increase the tenant didn’t see coming. Burnam’s approach is to leave nothing to be surprised by: “Something that we’re very upfront with our customers on is we tell them that this is a promotional rate.”

The sharpest surprises come when a promotional rate ends. A Cincinnati tenant told WCPO her 10x20 went from $173 to $285 a month while the same facility advertised $84 to new customers. When she complained, she was told the increase was in her contract, and her story ended up on the local news instead of being settled at the counter.

That expectation gets set at move-in and repeated before the rate changes. “In the era of pricing transparency, it’s important to be able to explain to a customer the benefit that they’re getting via this discount in a way that doesn’t feel like a bait and switch,” says Burnam. His team sends “plenty of advance notice and frequent reminders” that frame the change around what the tenant saved: “Over the first 90 days, you’ve saved X dollars in your unit. Good for you. Most people were paying more than that.”

Other ways operators are making the price path clearer:

  • Word the promo with an end date. Melissa Stiles of Storage Asset Management said on the webinar that her team is testing offers like “free rent to the end of the year” instead of “two months free.”

  • Give real notice. Plan on at least 30 days’ written notice, and check your state’s rules on timing and format.

  • Test pricing that’s predictable up front. Public Storage CEO Tom Boyle said on the company’s Q3 2026 earnings call that its fixed annual pricing tests communicate “a little bit more clarity around what pricing and rents will be for a customer in the first 12 months.” StoragePRO has tested rate locks at some locations.

Know What the Offer Should Be Before You Pick Up

The weakest version of a pushback call is a manager improvising, either holding the line with “it’s in your contract” or rolling the whole increase back to end the conversation, and both are guesses. The better answer depends on the tenant and the unit, and most of it can be decided in advance.

Burnam’s team built a small internal tool for this, an attempt to take what a great store manager knows about a customer off the top of their head and “bottle all that up into a formula.” The inputs are the ones any operator can pull from their FMS:

  • Demand for the unit. A tenant in a unit group sitting at 20% vacancy is a different call than one in the last 10x20 on the property.

  • Their rate against the unit average. If most tenants pay $200 for that unit and this one is at $90 coming off a promo, there’s little room to give.

  • Replacement value. If the unit had to be re-rented tomorrow, what would the new customer be worth over their stay?

Tenant traits matter too. Large-unit renters tend to stay longer and are less sensitive to increases, partly because moving a 10x30 is a project, while “someone renting a 5-by-5 can easily pack that up and move to a less expensive facility,” Ahmet Kuyumcu, CEO of Prorize, told Modern Storage Media. In the same piece, Jackson Stevens, CEO of SpareBox Technologies, named autopay as the single strongest predictor of whether a tenant moves out.

The REITs are thinking about the same problem. Asked on Public Storage’s Q3 call whether AI agents could make it easier for tenants to push back on ECRIs, Boyle said the company hadn’t seen more review requests so far, and that if they rise, “we will navigate that with the same sort of predictive analytics around customer behavior and vacate patterns.”

Offer Less Than You Think, and More Than a Rate Cut

When relief is warranted, it usually doesn’t mean undoing the increase. “Maybe instead of raising your rent 10%, we raise it 5%,” says Burnam. His team also found that a bigger concession didn’t buy more acceptances: “there’s no difference in a customer’s acceptance rate if we lower it by 20% or 10%. So, there’s no need to unnecessarily give more relief than they’re even expecting.”

The rate isn’t the only thing you can offer, either. Operators use a range of concessions that cost less than a cut:

  • Phase it in. DuBroc’s team will, in specific cases, spread an increase over two months, or adjust the tenant’s billing date.

  • Trade stability for commitment. On Track is testing a “loyalty lock” that holds a tenant’s rate for nine months in exchange for enrolling in autopay and tenant protection.

  • Offer a smaller unit. Mila Ailey of StoragePug suggests presenting a downsize as a way to solve the problem together, without pushing it.

  • Point to what’s improved. New cameras, gate access or keyless locks give the increase a reason, though not every tenant will care.

Whatever you offer, log it. Recording who called, what they were offered, whether they accepted and whether they were still renting 90 days later is how you find your own version of Burnam’s 10%-vs-20% line.

Let the First Person Who Answers Resolve It, Within Limits

A tenant who has to wait for a callback from a district manager has time to shop competitors and write a review. Modern Storage Media notes that unresolved rate concerns can quickly turn into negative online reviews. Burnam’s goal is “first touch resolution, immediately at the counter, on the phone.”

That takes two things. The first is authority with a ceiling. Scott, of Spartan Investment Group, recommends empowering managers to handle these conversations and, if they can negotiate, setting limits on how far they can reduce an increase. Where that authority sits depends on your size. Tim Springer of Avid Storage said on the webinar that a small operator with one layer of management usually gives property managers “more negotiation power, more overridability on rates,” while a growing portfolio tends to move it up to a supervisor who can “negotiate a rate or resolve an objection.”

The second is training. Sue Haviland of Haviland Storage Services ties most rate complaints to managers who were never taught to handle “the type of things that cause objections.” DuBroc frames the goal for his staff plainly: “We train our team to treat every ECRI call as an opportunity to reinforce the relationship.”

Building Your Own Program

You don’t need a custom app to start. A simple pushback program covers six things:

  1. Keep increases proportionate. Moderate increases barely move churn, and the risk climbs steeply at the extremes.

  2. Tell promo tenants their rate is promotional at move-in, and remind them before it burns off.

  3. Send clear notice through more than one channel, so autopay tenants don’t find out from their bank statement.

  4. Decide who can make an offer at your size, and give them a ceiling.

  5. Put the right numbers in front of them: unit-group occupancy, the tenant’s rate against the unit average and current street rate.

  6. Log every request and outcome, then check 90-day retention to learn how much relief actually works for your stores.

Revenue management is built into Cubby, so the occupancy and rate data behind that offer is already in front of the person taking the call, and Cubby’s ECRI recommendations factor in churn risk before the notice ever goes out. If you want to see how your stores compare on ECRIs, delinquency and move-ins, book a demo and we’ll walk through a free benchmark analysis.

Watch the full State of Self Storage webinar with Adam Burnam, Tim Springer and Melissa Stiles here, or download the report here.

Join the operators making the switch

Join the operators making the switch

Join the operators making the switch